In a recent decision handed down by the UK’s Intellectual Property Enterprise Court, a patent alleged to have been infringed by Hamilton Medical was found to be invalid.
The case had been brought against Hamilton Medical AG ("Hamilton") by Fleur Tehrani in November 2019, alleging that Hamilton’s INTELLiVENT-ASV* ventilator control system infringed certain claims of Tehrani’s existing patent. Hamilton denied these allegations, arguing that Tehrani’s patent was so broad that it covered what was already known in earlier control systems pre-dating Tehrani’s patent. and therefore could not be valid.
The decision confirmed Hamilton’s argument. Although found to cover INTELLiVENT-ASV, the patent was invalid because it was not new - its subject matter had been clearly and unambiguously disclosed in a publication dating from 1995. This success for Hamilton brings to an end the dispute commenced by Fleur Tehrani in the UK.
*Not available in all markets
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional training or for standard treatment guidelines in your facility. Any recommendations made in this article with respect to clinical practice or the use of specific products, technology or therapies represent the personal opinion of the author only, and may not be considered as official recommendations made by Hamilton Medical AG. Hamilton Medical AG provides no warranty with respect to the information contained in this article and reliance on any part of this information is solely at your own risk.